Are you looking to improve your digital strategy and track its success? As a serial entrepreneur, I know that digital marketing is a crucial aspect of any business model. That's why I'm going to share with you the top seven KPI metrics that every digital strategy agency should track and calculate.

  • Website Traffic: It's no secret that more website traffic can lead to more sales. By tracking your website traffic, you can identify which marketing efforts are bringing in the most visitors.
  • Social Media Engagement: Social media is an essential part of any digital strategy. By measuring your social media engagement, you can gauge the effectiveness of your content and adjust accordingly.

But those two KPIs are just the beginning. In this article, I'll go over five more crucial metrics that every digital strategy agency should track. From search engine rankings to customer satisfaction, we'll cover it all.

  • Improvement in Search Engine Rankings
  • Growth in Email Subscribers
  • Increase in Conversion Rates
  • Return on Investment for Digital Advertising Campaigns
  • Customer Satisfaction with Digital Branding and Marketing Efforts

Are you ready to take your digital strategy to the next level? Let's dive into these seven KPI metrics and learn how to track and calculate your success.



1. Increase in website traffic

As a digital strategy agency, measuring the success of your efforts is critical, and tracking key performance indicators (KPIs) is essential to achieving that goal. One such essential KPI to track is an increase in website traffic, which is the percentage increase in the number of website visits over a particular period.

Definition

Website traffic refers to the number of visitors who land on your website. Increasing website traffic means getting more people to visit a site, which is typically the first step in the process of converting them into valuable customers or clients.

Use Case

Increasing website traffic is an important goal for organizations that want to grow and succeed online. It is especially crucial for e-commerce sites that rely on online sales. More website traffic equals more leads, more sales opportunities, more brand exposure, and more word-of-mouth referrals.

How to Calculate KPI

Website traffic can be calculated by dividing the total number of website visits by the number of days in the period and multiplying that by 100 to express it as a percentage. The formula is as follows:

Website traffic = (Total Number of Visits / Number of Days) x 100%

Calculation Example

For example, if the total number of website visits for a week is 5,000, and the week has seven days:

Website traffic = (5,000 / 7) x 100% = 714.29%

KPI Advantages

  • It shows the effectiveness of your search engine optimization (SEO) and other digital marketing efforts, indicating whether they are driving more traffic to your site.
  • It helps you understand your website visitors' behavior and preferences, enabling you to tweak your website's design, layout, and content to improve its performance and conversion rate.

KPI Disadvantages

  • It may not necessarily mean your website is successful - traffic doesn't always equate to conversion or sales.
  • It can be affected by seasonal trends and fluctuations, which can skew the results.

KPI Industry Benchmarks

The benchmark for website traffic varies by industry, but a rate of 10% growth per month is considered a good baseline for most organizations.

Tips and Tricks

  • Track the website traffic of your competitors to get a sense of what's 'normal' for your industry and to identify areas where you can improve.
  • Use Google Analytics to measure website traffic and refine your digital marketing campaigns.
  • Invest in SEO and other digital marketing strategies to drive more traffic to your site, but always keep the big picture in mind: conversion and sales.


Excel financial model

Digital Strategy Agency Financial Model

  • 5-Year Excel Financial Projection
  • 40+ Charts & Metrics
  • DCF & Multiple Valuation
  • Free Email Support



Improvement in Search Engine Rankings

Definition

Improvement in search engine rankings is a key performance indicator that measures the success of digital marketing strategies aimed at improving a website's position in search engine results pages (SERPs). This KPI tracks whether the website's content and optimization efforts result in increased visibility and traffic from search engines.

Use Case

Improvement in search engine rankings is essential for businesses that rely on organic traffic to drive sales and generate leads. For instance, a digital strategy agency working with an e-commerce brand may focus on optimizing product pages and category pages to improve their ranking on search engines, which can result in more traffic and sales.

How To Calculate KPI

The formula for calculating the improvement in search engine rankings is:

(Search engine rankings - Baseline rankings) / Baseline rankings x 100

Calculation Example

Let's say a website's baseline ranking for a particular keyword is #10, and after implementing SEO strategies, its ranking improves to #5. Then, the calculation would be:

(5-10)/10 x 100 = -50%

The negative percentage indicates a decrease in rankings, which means the baseline ranking was higher than the current ranking.

KPI Advantages

  • Helps measure the effectiveness of search engine optimization strategies
  • Highlights areas for improvement and optimization
  • Provides a measurable way to track the impact of SEO efforts on website traffic and revenue

KPI Disadvantages

  • Does not account for changes in search engine algorithms or competitors' SEO strategies
  • May not reflect the website's overall traffic or revenue performance
  • Can be influenced by external factors like seasonality or industry trends

KPI Industry Benchmarks

Industry benchmarks for the improvement in search engine rankings KPI can vary depending on the website's industry and target keywords. Generally, an improvement of at least 10% is considered a significant improvement, while a decline of more than 10% is concerning.

Tips & Tricks

  • Regularly monitor search engine rankings and organic traffic to identify opportunities for improvement
  • Focus on optimizing for long-tail keywords to improve the website's visibility for specific, targeted searches
  • Create high-quality, relevant content that aligns with search intent and encourages engagement from users


3. Increase in Social Media Engagement

Social media has become a vital channel for businesses to reach their customers and promote their products and services. As a digital strategy agency, it is essential to track and improve the social media performance of your clients. One of the key metrics to evaluate social media success is the increase in social media engagement.

Definition

Social media engagement refers to the level of interaction a brand receives on social media platforms. This interaction includes likes, shares, comments, and followers. Measuring social media engagement is crucial as it indicates how well a brand is connecting with its audience on social media platforms.

Use Case

By tracking the increase in social media engagement, digital strategy agencies can determine if their social media campaigns are resonating well with their client's target audience. With this KPI, you can evaluate which social media platforms and content types are driving the most engagement. This information can then be used to optimize the client's social media strategy to drive more engagement, increase brand awareness, and generate more leads and sales.

How to Calculate KPI

To calculate the increase in social media engagement KPI:

KPI: (New Engagement - Old Engagement) / Old Engagement x 100

Calculation Example

Let's say your client's Instagram account had 100 likes, 20 comments, and 15 shares on a post before a social media campaign. After the campaign, the same post had 200 likes, 50 comments, and 30 shares. To calculate the KPI:

KPI: (300 - 135) / 135 x 100 = 122%

The increase in social media engagement for this campaign is 122%.

KPI Advantages

  • Helps to measure the effectiveness of social media campaigns over time
  • Allows analysis of which types of content resonate better with the target audience
  • Enables identification of which social media channels provide more engagement opportunities

KPI Disadvantages

  • Engagement metrics do not necessarily correlate with business outcomes
  • Social media engagement is affected by a variety of factors, including time of day, frequency of posting, algorithms, and ad spend
  • May not be enough to provide a comprehensive view of social media performance

KPI Industry Benchmarks

The average increase in social media engagement varies by industry and social media platform. Here are some benchmarks to consider:

  • Facebook: 0.5% to 1%
  • Instagram: 1% to 2%
  • Twitter: 0.05% to 0.09%
  • LinkedIn: 0.2% to 0.4%

Tips and Tricks

  • Create engaging content that resonates with the target audience
  • Use social media insights and analytics tools to track social media performance
  • Experiment with A/B testing to determine the best types of content to post


4. Growth in Email Subscribers

Definition

Growth in email subscribers is a metric used to measure the increase or decrease in the number of email subscribers over a period of time. Email subscribers are those who have opted to receive promotional and informational emails from a company.

Use Case

Growth in email subscribers is a valuable KPI for businesses who rely on email marketing to drive sales and generate revenue. Tracking this metric can help companies understand the effectiveness of their email campaigns and identify opportunities for improvement.

How to Calculate KPI

To calculate growth in email subscribers, we need to determine the net increase or decrease in the number of email subscribers over a predefined period. The formula for calculating growth in email subscribers is:

(Number of new subscribers - Number of unsubscribes) / Total number of subscribers at the beginning of the period) x 100

Calculation Example

Let's assume our company had 10,000 subscribers at the beginning of the quarter, gained 2,000 new subscribers, and had 800 unsubscribes over the same period. Using the formula above, we can calculate the growth in email subscribers:

((2,000 - 800) / 10,000) x 100 = 12%

Therefore, our growth in email subscribers for the quarter is 12%.

KPI Advantages

  • Provides insight into the effectiveness of email marketing campaigns
  • Allows businesses to identify areas for improvement and optimize campaigns
  • Can help businesses track the impact of promotions and other marketing initiatives

KPI Disadvantages

  • Does not account for changes in overall market conditions
  • Net subscriber growth may not accurately represent the effectiveness of email campaigns
  • Changes in subscriber behavior (such as spam complaints or inactive subscribers) may skew results

KPI Industry Benchmarks

Industry benchmarks for growth in email subscribers vary widely depending on the type of business and the industry. However, an average growth rate of 10-15% per quarter is generally considered to be healthy for most businesses.

Tips & Tricks

  • Offer an incentive for users to sign up for emails, such as a discount or free eBook
  • Make sure your email sign-up form is easy to find and prominent on your website
  • Regularly clean your email list to remove inactive users and spam complaints


5. Increase in Conversion Rates

Definition

Conversion rates refer to the percentage of website visitors who complete a desired action, such as making a purchase or filling out a form. An increase in conversion rates signifies improved performance in converting leads into customers.

Use Case

Tracking conversion rates is crucial for digital strategy agencies, as it helps to determine the effectiveness of campaigns and identify areas for improvement. A higher conversion rate indicates that the agency is successfully targeting its audience and driving more leads towards conversion.

How To Calculate KPI

To calculate the increase in conversion rates, use the following formula:

Conversion Rate Increase = (New Conversion Rate - Old Conversion Rate) / Old Conversion Rate * 100

Calculation Example

Suppose a digital strategy agency had a conversion rate of 2% last quarter. This quarter, the agency implemented new tactics and increased the conversion rate to 3%. To calculate the increase in conversion rates:

Conversion Rate Increase = (3 - 2) / 2 * 100 = 50%

The increase in conversion rates is 50%. This indicates that the agency's efforts in improving the conversion process were successful.

KPI Advantages

  • Indicates the effectiveness of campaigns in driving leads towards conversion
  • Helps to identify areas for improvement in the conversion process
  • Provides a clear metric for measuring the ROI of digital marketing efforts

KPI Disadvantages

  • May not take into account external factors that can impact conversion rates, such as seasonal trends or market changes
  • Conversion rates can be influenced by several variables that are not directly related to the efficacy of digital marketing efforts, such as the user experience on a website or the quality of the product or service being offered
  • Conversion rate optimization can be a complex and ongoing process

KPI Industry Benchmarks

The average conversion rate across industries is approximately 2.35%. However, this can vary widely depending on the industry and the specific nature of the product or service being offered. Therefore, it is important for digital strategy agencies to research and establish industry benchmarks for their clients.

Tips & Tricks

  • Regularly A/B test landing pages and calls-to-action to improve conversion rates
  • Make sure your website is optimized for mobile devices to capture a larger audience
  • Use analytics tools like Google Analytics to track user behavior and identify areas for improvement


6. Return on investment for digital advertising campaigns

Definition

Return on investment (ROI) is a performance metric used to evaluate the efficiency of an investment. It measures how much return an investment generates relative to its cost. When it comes to digital advertising campaigns, ROI is used to determine the profit gained from the investment in the campaign compared to the cost of running said campaign.

Use Case

Measuring ROI for digital advertising campaigns is important to determine whether or not the campaign was successful and profitable. It helps businesses make informed decisions on how and where to allocate their budgets for future campaigns. Additionally, it also aids in calculating the actual amount of revenue the campaign generated and the overall return on investment for the organization.

How To Calculate KPI

To calculate ROI for digital advertising campaigns, you need to divide the profit by the cost of the campaign. The formula for calculating ROI is:

    (Revenue - Cost of goods sold) / Cost of goods sold

Calculation Example

Let's say a business spends $10,000 on a digital advertising campaign and, as a result, earns $12,000 in revenue. The calculation for ROI would look like this:

    ($12,000 - $10,000) / $10,000 = 0.2 or 20%

KPI Advantages

  • Easy to calculate and understand
  • Helps identify the most profitable campaigns
  • Assists in making informed decisions on future budget allocations

KPI Disadvantages

  • Does not take into account indirect benefits or costs
  • Does not factor in the withstanding effects of branding and customer loyalty
  • Difficult to measure for campaigns with long-term goals

KPI Industry Benchmarks

The benchmark for ROI in digital advertising campaigns varies by industry and company. However, according to a study conducted by AdStage, the average ROI for Facebook advertising campaigns across industries was 152% in 2019.

Tips & Tricks

  • Tip 1: Focus on creating a campaign that targets the right audience. This can significantly improve the ROI of the campaign.
  • Tip 2: Measure ROI for every campaign you run. By understanding which campaigns brought the highest ROI, you can allocate funds more efficiently in the future.
  • Tip 3: Use A/B testing to optimize campaigns for a higher ROI. By testing different creatives, ad copies, or calls-to-action, you can find what works best for your target audience and improves your ROI.


7. Customer satisfaction with digital branding and marketing efforts

Definition

Customer satisfaction with digital branding and marketing efforts is a KPI that measures how satisfied customers are with a business's online branding and marketing efforts. This metric provides insight into how well a business is connecting with its target audience and if its marketing strategies are working.

Use Case

This KPI is particularly important for businesses that rely heavily on digital marketing and branding to attract and retain customers. It helps businesses assess the effectiveness of their online marketing strategies and identify areas where improvements can be made.

How To Calculate KPI

To calculate customer satisfaction with digital branding and marketing efforts, divide the number of satisfied customers by the total number of customers and multiply by 100. The formula for this KPI is:

Satisfied Customers / Total Customers * 100 = Customer Satisfaction with Digital Branding and Marketing Efforts KPI

Calculation Example

Let's say a business has 1,000 customers and 800 of them are satisfied with the company's digital branding and marketing efforts. To calculate the KPI, we would use the following formula:

800 / 1,000 * 100 = 80% Customer Satisfaction with Digital Branding and Marketing Efforts KPI

KPI Advantages

  • Helps businesses identify areas of improvement in their digital marketing and branding strategies
  • Provides valuable insights into customer satisfaction and overall branding effectiveness
  • Assesses customer retention likelihood and long-term business success

KPI Disadvantages

  • Low response rates may skew results and not reflect overall customer satisfaction
  • Does not account for customer feedback and concerns beyond digital marketing efforts
  • Results may vary depending on demographics targeted and other external factors

KPI Industry Benchmarks

According to a recent study by HubSpot, the average customer satisfaction rate for digital marketing efforts across all industries is 63%. However, it's important to note that industry benchmarks may vary greatly depending on the target demographic and overall market conditions.

Tips and Tricks:

  • Conduct customer surveys to capture feedback and opinions on digital marketing strategies
  • Make changes based on customer feedback to improve overall branding and marketing effectiveness
  • Regularly monitor KPI results to track progress over time


Measuring the success of your digital strategy is crucial in today's business world. By tracking the right KPI metrics, you can make well-informed decisions, adjust your marketing efforts, and ultimately drive more sales.

In this article, we've covered the top seven KPI metrics that every digital strategy agency should track. Starting with website traffic and social media engagement, we've gone on to explain the importance of monitoring your search engine rankings, email subscribers, conversion rates, digital advertising ROI, and customer satisfaction.

As you work to develop and improve your digital strategy, keep these KPI metrics in mind and measure your progress towards achieving your business goals. By doing so, you'll be able to make data-driven decisions that lead to business growth and success.

Excel financial model

Digital Strategy Agency Financial Model
  • 5-Year Financial Projection
  • 40+ Charts & Metrics
  • DCF & Multiple Valuation
  • Free Email Support